I was in the market a little while ago and went throught the samething. In fact i was looking at the same tires, Nitto, BFG, and Procomp. I had a set of BFG a/t on my 94 Dakota, side note i will never own a dodge again. I had the 5.2 v8 and it was seriously one of the most gutless things i have driven. That being said, it would lite the BFGs up with out hesitation if there was any moisture on the road. They wore pretty well and were great in the dirt but i didn't trust them in the rain. I was looking at the Nittos but heard countless stories of how they wore badly. Next up was the Pro comp a/t. I heard a ton of positive feedback from owners and they cost less to boot. If you want to go with one of those three Pro comp is the way i'd go. I was informed that Cooper tire made the tires for Pro comp but couldn't find out for sure. Anyway i was looking at some of the Cooper tires and settled on the Discoverer a/t. They have a 50,000 mile warranty and have great customer ratings. I decided to give them a try and I can honestly say that i'm very impressed. They are load range E ten ply tires and they only ran me 120 a tire. I picked them up at discount tire and have taken through the mud, dry trail, snow, rain, ice and slush. They have worked much better than any other tire i have used. I vote for the Cooper.